Home
Centre for the Study of the Sciences and the Humanities

Ethics of quantification

In 2019, Ethics of quantification was the theme for the Centre for the Study of the Sciences and the Humanities (SVT)'s annual symposium.

ordene quanitifaction
Photo:
123RF

Main content

This year, the theme is ‘Ethics of Quantification’. The intermeshing of algorithms and big data increasingly blurs many existing distinctions between different forms of quantification and is gaining prominence in the nascent field of the sociology of quantification. As Elizabeth Popp Berman and Daniel Hirschman enquire: “What qualities are specific to rankings, or indicators, or models, or algorithms?” In recent times, examples of quantification have come under intense scrutiny with regard to perceived misuse or abuse of existing methodologies. Algorithms pose the risk of non-transparent, oft-proprietary tools being used to decide upon everything from convicting felons to conceding mortgages, and from recruitment to adoption. Quantification as a policy support tool is also found wanting. The convulsions of significance testing in statistics have received wide attention in both media and academia. Mathematical modelling is a field where severe problems are not yet fully charted. Common to many forms of quantification is a singular conundrum: any number which does not represent its context and purpose of production can obfuscate as much as it can illuminate. Is time ripe for an ethics of quantification?

The symposium on 6th of December 2019 will feature keynotes by prominent scholars of Science and Technology Studies, the politics of metrics, and the ethics, fungibility and policy relevance of quantification. We are delighted to welcome professor in History of Science, Theodore Porter,UCLA, Professor emerita Catherine Paradeise, Université Paris-Est, Ana Viseu, Associate Professor at Universidade Europeia together with SVTs Andrea Saltelli as our distinguished keynote speakers. 

The closing round table of the symposium will be introduced and chaired by SVTs Jeroen van der Sluijs.

Mimi Lam and Kjetil Rommetveit from SVT working on quantification and cognate themes are chairing sessions of a research workshop anchored by Siddharth Sareen and Andrea Saltelli on the same theme, which will be held a day prior to the symposium, December 5th – please see the call for papers.

Programme

6 December 2019

09.00 Coffee  

09.30 Welcome by Pro-rector Margareth Hagen and Introduction by Director at SVT Rasmus Slaatelid. 

10.00 Theodore Porter, UCLA:
The Dubious Economy of Data-Driven Management

10.45 Q&A, Chair: Rasmus Slaatlied.

11.00 Ana Viseu, Universidade Europeia:
Recovering Difference as a Site of Intervention: The case of wearable computers  

11.45 Q&A  Chair: Anne Bremer

12.00 Lunch  

12.45 Andrea Saltelli, University of Bergen:
Ethics of quantification or quantification of ethics?

13.30 Q&A  Chair: Anne Bremer

13.45 Catherine Paradeise, The Eastern Paris Federal University:
Quantifying has become a business. The issues of metrics in higher education

14.30 Q&A  Chair: Silje Langvatn

14.45 Coffee 

15.00 Panel based on research workshop Session I: AI and big data, Chair: Kjetil Rommetveit, University of Bergen

15:45 Panel based on workshop session II: Governing subjects through numbers, Chair: Mimi Lam, University of Bergen

16.30 Plenary discussion and conclusions, Chair: Jeroen van der Sluijs, University of Bergen 

17:30 End

19.00 SVT and Speakers dinner